Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts

4/16/14

Some Thoughts on Richard Blanco

Photo by Jennifer Trivedi

Last night, the President of Roger Williams University, where I am an adjunct, hosted Richard Blanco, the poet now famous for having read at President Obama's Second Inauguration. To Blanco's credit, he seems just as surprised as anyone that he was invited to read at such an event and he seems to have taken this as a mandate to speak for poetry to the American people. He is nearly a rockstar, invited to events everywhere and writing poems for various events and causes. He even showed his own face on a billboard promoting a cause he believes in. Strange to see a poet on a billboard.

Frankly, we, the American poetry community, need it, to an extent. No, I am not with Dana Gioia in that we should get back to poets being super important parts of American life but I do think we need someone who is willing to be the person who travels around showing that poetry in America is very much alive. For the most part, this is where we, in our creative writing programs, etc., run into issues. I think that poetry for most people is not just inaccessible, but something that have no desire to access even if time permitted. That is very unlikely to change, of course. It seems very likely to me that poetry will remain for poets in our society and that it will be hard to grow into the general reading public on our own.

And I am certainly not suggesting that poetry should be accessible for the sake of sales, etc. Poetry should be chaotic thought but I do feel there should be a way into that chaotic thought. I do not think that the poetry community does anything for language/writing or any community by being more available simply to be popular to the general population, which is unlikely to happen regardless. However, that does not mean that poetry should not have a way in and I believe Blanco is a perfectly interesting way into the world of poetry.

He did something last night which surprised me a bit: he did not just read poems, he gave a talk about himself, his experiences and, to an extent, the role that poetry has played in his life and the role he hopes poetry can play in the lives of others. I think this is really important as it seems much of the poetry community has deemed this beneath them- and maybe it is to a certain extent- but simply pointing out the role of poetry in modern society does not seem like something to be shunned and it certainly does not seem like we, as poets, should dismiss the non-poetry-reading-community for not immediately being inclined towards reading poetry without a way in.

I think fiction has a nice balance here. We read narratives from a very young age. Children's literature is all about creating, however simple, a narrative. Poetry is always going to be a step beyond that and we should not feel guilty for that but we should accept that there must be some way into the world of deeper reading that perhaps does not exist outside of the university setting, for better or for worse. And, again, perhaps it is perfectly fine the modern poetry has its space within academia but that does not mean there should be not attempt at all to take the various goals of contemporary writing beyond that public.

The crowd at RWU last night was interesting. It was advertised across the school and through the town of Bristol, RI and the surrounding community. Basically, beyond our own creative writing department, there was still a good crowd of folks who, more than likely, would never have seen a poetry event come along, much less attend such a thing. This is Blanco's power now, to bring people into the world of poets and poetry. From there, people are free to do what they like. As RWU's President said to me after Blanco's talk, now people have to choose what they want to do but having Blanco there gives people that choice. Maybe folks will read more poetry, maybe they'll never read a poem again- who knows, but now that option is there.

Blanco even said as much in his talk. For whatever reason, poetry (and a few other art forms) seem to turn people off very quickly. If you do not get one poem or one thing, it becomes immediately inaccessible and, I would argue, because there is no desire in American society to go further into anything that is not immediately accessible, people avoid it, often by dismissing it with that favorite word, "difficult."

When I spoke with Blanco after, I noted how tired he looked. All this is weighing down on him, I said to him. Not only does all of this keep him busy but he also feels he has a task in an attempting to get poetry back out of the classroom and into the hands of ordinary citizens. I mentioned to him that Jackie Robinson took it upon himself, after his years in baseball, to become an ambassador of sorts for Civil Rights in this country. He felt he was in a unique position to help the movement by speaking his opinion. This is not to say Blanco is in any way like Robinson (which he laughed at when I mentioned the idea) but like Robinson, attempting to be on the forefront of something could be very difficult, long-term, on him personally.

But perhaps the sacrifice is important. Maybe it is something that, because so few are willing to do it, must fall on him. He has been given a unique position among American poets to do something which we cannot, even if it is not something anyone would ask for. I think that while the folks who I consider my own cohort are doing interesting work, there should be someone saying that there is a role for poetry in American society. Maybe that will never happen- maybe it never SHOULD happen, but that does not mean there should not be someone saying it. Richard Blanco, for the moment, seems to be that person.

Maybe he is not the ideal candidate- I have not even discussed his work- but at the present time, he seems to have some kind of hold on the population at large and if poetry is what he is promoting, perhaps we should not be too quick to judge him for how he handles it all. (Honestly, how would any of us handle such a thing?) He has something most poets in this country never will, the ear of the public. Perhaps his opinions and thoughts will not land him on the cover of Time Magazine, but there are people who will give some thought to his comments. Is that not something we as a poetry community can at least be somewhat appreciative for, even if we do not agree 100% with all of it? Surely some will be unable to reconcile these things, but I think having someone who is quite concerned with the role of poetry in society having a place in the public sphere is not a bad thing.

9/14/09

Fashion Poetics V: The Empire Strikes Back

I’m not immediately against Capitalism. Well, I guess I’m more against it now than I ever was before, but ultimately, it’s not the worst system. I do believe, to some extent, in the personal freedom that *ought* to come with Capitalism- in that you’re not living in some despotic Communist-in-name-only country. I figure if you want, you should be able to own a business and sell stuff you want.

Same goes for presses, of course. Publish what you want. You have more money; you publish more stuff you want. Sometimes it sells, which means you ought to sell it, right?

Not exactly. Looking back on some of the early Fashion Poetics posts, I got to thinking again about the analogous nature of fashion with poetry: there’s fashion that goes on the runway and fashion that sells at K-Mart. Some might argue that the “fashion” at K-Mart isn’t fashion at all, but rather a utility, but at some level, it was designed with an aesthetic in mind.

Of course, I’m hard-pressed to call something utility clothing, because by extension that means there’s utility poetry- poetry that serves a basic function and sells in high quantities just so people can buy some poetry for whatever reason (actually- why do people buy utility poetry?). To say that there’s utility poetry means there’s someone out there writing poetry in order to sell it, and maybe I’m just not that cynical.

But maybe I should pretend for a while. Maybe I should consider that beyond someone writing poetry in order to sell it, they’re writing poems they think are meeting a certain aesthetic, like the clothes on the rack at K-Mart (which, I should say here, I’m not knocking- do I look like I’m a high fashion guy?). You hope to meet a certain aesthetic and they hope you buy it, thinking you’re meeting that aesthetic.

But you’re not, and they’re playing you. They are crafters of a pseudo-aesthetic style that makes sense to the great majority of people. “These are jeans. They fit. I bet they’ll look good.” However, my guess is, for Fashionistas, there’s a lot more to even just basic jeans that maybe the average person wouldn’t give a shit about.

Don’t get me wrong: I’m not saying poetry should attempt to be beyond the reach of the average person, but maybe what I’m saying is that it should not apologize for it. Poetry should not feel bad for being “difficult,” if anyone can define that term. Poetry shouldn’t attempt to play to any denominator because maybe it shouldn’t end up on a mass-consumption rack.

It might not sell. It’s not supposed to sell. It’s supposed to be pushing the edges of what we understand language to be. Well, maybe not, but your aesthetic ought to be whatever you make it, but selling it should not be your goal. If it is your goal, I suppose you’re what I’m railing against.

Back to the earlier question: why do people buy their poetry from Barnes and Noble or the other big chains? Is there anything interesting there? I think it has to do with poetry being viewed as some kind of higher level- some kind of elite tradition which, by not only shopping in the poetry section at B&N, but also having it on your bookshelf at home, you’ve now included yourself in. Poetry is considered, as Johannes once said, “high falutin’” and it’s something you’re into when you’re attempting to appear superior to others. However, all you’re doing is continuing to support the established set by considering it in that way and buying with that in mind.1

While I say poetry should not apologize for being “difficult,” I think that’s separate from what I believe most poets want to say about their work these days. Yeah, I’d say my poems are a bit weird, but there’s nothing to “get” about them necessarily, a common complaint I hear. “These are kind of cool, Amish, I just don’t get poetry.” Neither do I, to be honest.

This Fashion metaphor isn’t perfect. What I suppose I mean by it is that yes there are channels and options in poetry like anything else and simply because something appears not to have a practical use doesn’t mean it’s useless. Poetry doesn’t need to comfort or make you feel anything about a specific event. I’m reminded by a book of “Friendship Poems” that I have, given to me by David. Is it necessary to categorize poetry in that way? Aren’t all poems love poems or hate poems in some way? Aren’t they all about friendship and death and all these topics common to the “human experience?” Maybe poetry isn’t any of those things at the same time.

Art, I feel, has its own merit beyond its ability to sell, or at least it should. It should be more about the limits and pushing past them, which should not be tied to sales or even jobs. In fact, on the subject of jobs, I think poets ought to be hired for how far they are outside of the norm within a department, not how well they meet it. ‘Ars gratia artis’ and all that.

_____________________________________________________________________________

1 Do Non-Poets Buy Poetry Books?

5/23/09

Note

I'm alive, just have nothing terribly good to write about of late. Still working on "Sound/Chest." Planning a move to Providence at the end of July. Took a trip there last week and had a blast.

Oh, and Jennifer's a Mets fan. I feel betrayed, but at least she's kind of getting into baseball.

My fantasy team sucks again.

Sold a bunch of books and bought pants.

Thinking about buying some cheap guitar pedals from Danelectro- like $12 a pop. They seem to sound good and I don't do a lot of "stomping."

Our place in Providence is out of our price range but happily worth it. It's beautiful and the landlord is a classy guy, much like our current landlord, Kermit. We've had some luck, to say the least.

Jennifer's sister Annie is graduating from high school this coming week. She's heading to Syracuse. My wife and I will be within 5 hours of each of her sisters. And Cooperstown. And Waterbury, VT, home of Ben and Jerry's. There's a factory tour.

I'm thinking about writing a poem for an event. It's a good choice in terms of "events," but I feel strange that my mind is wandering towards it. Fortunately, when asked initially, I said I wouldn't write something, but rather find something to read. It will be a happy surprise for the event planners, no doubt.

I'm happy that Keith Waldrop is teaching the first workshop next Fall. It was an incredible honor meeting him and his wife of so many years, Rosmarie. She spent a lot of time with us at a reading while in Providence and she was so kind.

The other class I'm thinking of taking is on Modernism in the English department. It's being taught by Mutlu Blasing and I've read some great essays from her. She has a book on form and politics in poetry. Sounds right up the alley I was heading in the Nowak essay.

My last day of work at Media Services is July 16.

I've been in a Leonard Cohen mood lately, not quite a "Leonard Cohen afterworld," though.

3/26/09

Fashion Poetics IV Addendum

Poets.org's list of "Most Popular Contemporary Poets" for 2008:


1. Billy Collins
2. Gwendolyn Brooks
3. Charles Simic
4. Nikki Giovanni
5. Gary Soto
6. Allen Ginsberg
7. Kay Ryan
8. Rita Dove
9. Adrienne Rich
10. Naomi Shihab Nye
11. Mary Oliver
12. John Ashbery
13. Donald Hall
14. Louise Glück
15. Lucille Clifton
16. Sharon Olds
17. Yusef Komunyakaa
18. Sonia Sanchez
19. Jane Kenyon
20. Mark Strand


Sweet Jesus. Ginsberg? I love the guy, but he's not Contemporary. "Contemporary to what?" I suppose is the question.

Actually, let's take this a step further (from Dictionary.reference.com):

con⋅tem⋅po⋅rar⋅y   /kənˈtɛmpəˌrɛri/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [kuhn-tem-puh-rer-ee] Show IPA adjective, noun, plural -rar⋅ies.
–adjective 1. existing, occurring, or living at the same time; belonging to the same time: Newton's discovery of the calculus was contemporary with that of Leibniz.
2. of about the same age or date: a Georgian table with a contemporary wig stand.
3. of the present time; modern: a lecture on the contemporary novel.

–noun 4. a person belonging to the same time or period with another or others.
5. a person of the same age as another.


Let's go with #3, "of present time." This list is a Barnes and Noble list of poets and people that people have heard of. Brooks? Love her stuff. Dead. Not contemporary, I'm sorry to say.

I suppose this actually has little to do with the issue of 'difficult' poetry, other than having come directly from the previous posting's thoughts on canon. I suppose the only real point I could make here is that these are the people that end up in textbooks and in high school heads and ears. OK, so very few of these people are in textbooks, but the mentality is there. And I think the only reason some folks are on this list is because there are people who vote them up with no real interest in moving beyond a canon. They're interested in perpetuating the same group of people they've been thinking about and hearing about for the last 30 years.

Fashion Poetics IV: "I Don't Get This Kind of Fashion"

Jennifer got back from Santa Fe, New Mexico on Monday. Getting back into our normal schedule of TV watching, last night I happened to watch a few minutes of that Bravo show "Make Me a Supermodel." Now, I tried watching a few episodes last season, and I hated it. I also don't like it much now, but I don't mind hanging out with my wife while she's working on her comprehensive exam question(s).

Last night though, I did catch something she said, and catch something on the screen at the same time: people dressed in strange wire type outfits (maybe it was a repeat? who knows). What caught my attention was Jennifer's statement: "I don't get this kind of fashion."

It made me think again about my on going thoughts on poetry and what fashion can teach us about poetry and what people generally seem to understand and not understand. This, again, comes down to the word "difficult": the wire outfits are no doubt difficult for myself and I imagine what must be the Bravo audience (guys waiting for baseball season to begin, maybe?).

A quick search of "most popular poet" (which I assumed would yield your Romantics) brought up a poll of Top 10 Poems, as polled by the Classic Poetry Aloud website. Be shocked that everyone but Kipling was dead before 1900 (Kipling dying in 1936) and that with the exception of a Shakespeare sonnet, everything else is 19th century (and the Kipling poem I suppose is 1910).

It seems strange to say this, but for most people, it seems poetry stopped existing as soon as they saw Prufrock or something! As if there was a collective throwing up of hands and shouting "I'm out!" and since that point, new poetry has existed as a counter-public, with the exceptions of your Collins's and Pinskies, who seem to be read as an example of what's out there currently. Otherwise, poetry exists in a little vacuum: we read, write, and publish for each other- our own incestous bubble. Contemporary poetry has been cast out of the main stream, it seems

I want to mention here that I don't think that's a problem with poetry or poets: it's the way we teach poetry in schools and beyond. We test kids to death on "sinews of the heart" from Blake, but exclude, until you're in a creative writing or contemporary poetry class at University level, anything particularly new. If you're lucky, you *might* get Plath or Ginsberg in high school text books. Of course you never get to it since teachers are busy with all sorts of other issues, including standardized tests, which make sure you're up on your Keats and Shelley.

So back to "getting it": it seems simple that the main issue is this idea that poetry and everything else ought to be understood and be able to be absorbed within the first reading. If we like, we can call this the "Soundbyte Effect" in which everything should be able to be ascertained within 3 to 5 seconds and the rest can be discarded for YouTube.

Poetry should function the same way, it seems. There ought to be understandable words and language. There ought to be a theme that's understandable immediately, hence the popularlity of love and war and death. There ought to be rhythm and meter because if there's not, why not write an essay? Lines ought to rhyme (slant rhymes acceptable).

Of course, this is all stupid: death is boring and so is love. Can you define love? How about defining a sandwich?

We've seen an evolved path in the 20th century (ok- so there are folks that were doing it before, but I mean a concrete "system") where in poetry is allowed to move beyond the restrictions of previous generations, and yet, it is this that seems to be enjoyed by a public who find "comfort" in Romanticism.

"Getting" poetry isn't necessarily something that's good: poetry, I feel, ought to be something you have to work out and yes, if you're looking for pleasure in poetry, perhaps you'd be better off sticking with people incredibly dead (not the recent folks, of course). If poetry should or ought to be relaxing to you, perhaps it's best to avoid modern poetry.

However, I believe writing and reading modern poetry is a challenge and ought to be challenging. There's a lot going on and life too is complex. Poetry ought to meet the complexities of modern life and the complexities of modern language and its usage.

So yeah, it sucks not "getting" a certain type of fashion. But maybe we're not supposed to "get" it. The goal is individualized and removed from objective measurement, though for some reason Make Me a Super Model seems to be running a show of objectivity.

3/14/09

Brown University



After a phone call today from Brown University, I immediately said yes, agreeing to come to school there this Fall. I'll be working towards an M.F.A. in poetry in their Literary Arts program.

I was holding out on Brown, but honestly I had wonderful offers Notre Dame's M.F.A. and Illinois State's MA program, for which I was offered a wonderful fellowship.

As readers of this blog will note, this hasn't been without a lot of hard work over the last years, and a great part of that is the patience of friends and family, and especially my wife, Jennifer. She has been through a lot with me, with a lot more crap to sludge through, I'm sure.

I must also thank Johannes, G.C. and Joyelle for what I imagine must have been wonderful letters of recommendation. It's so strange to have one part of your file that you have absolutely no idea about, but that could have made a huge difference. That these three were willing to take a chance on me four years into my Iowan exile truly means the world to me. I'll never be able to thank them enough.

We'll be moving there this August, and while we're really going to miss Iowa City, I think it's the perfect time for me to start school and get on with my life. Jennifer is coming with of course, though she'll be heading off to do Ph.D. field work for her Anthropology degree. We'll be apart some, but again, this is the time to do it.

Anyways, we're so excited- today has been an incredible Friday the 13th, certainly- and there's just so much to think about and look forward to. There will be some things to stress out about, but for now, I'm going to enjoy it.

3/1/09

Setting

I'm kind of weirded out of late by people talking about "where" they write: what kind of lighting they use. What music they listen to. Do they use candles? Is there a mountain outside or a lake? Maybe it's snowing and there's something inspirational about the snow.

Maybe music sounds interesting. Johannes always suggested throwing on Godard's "Pierrot le fou" in the back ground. I recall him getting in some hot water over his regular exercise at the time: showing Un Chien Andalou and having the class write while it was going on in the background. I'm quite certain I got some cool poems from that exercise, but my "hot water" comment clearly shows that I'm one of the few who thought the practice was great. Apparently for others, it was a reason to complain that they weren't "being taught to write."

I'm bothered that someone writing is a Romantic or ritualistic practice, like somehow you'll just have pages of words flowing as soon as you get the perfect mise en scene down. It reminds me of people that go and by special notebooks and pens and expect that these are the things that create good poems or stories or whatever.

I guess I'm just over it. I don't know if I can write anywhere or whatever, and I'm not saying that a location isn't important. I'm just saying a location isn't going to make you better or worse or make you more or less creative. If you're inspired by the snow or mountains, perhaps you ought examine what you're really doing.

For another thing: can anyone teach you to write? I don't think that's the goal of the workshop or the MFA, for that matter. I think the best anyone can do for you is give you the space to write and time to do it. The workshop, at its best, is a place for feedback and learning to think critically about yourself and others.

Anyways, spaces and places, lights and sights. What good are these things if your poems suck anyways?

2/13/09

Happy Poetry Day!

Since we've been living in Iowa City, which puts us at 3 1/2 years as of February 1st, I've been working from noon until 9pm, Sunday through Thursday, most of the time. The exceptions are school breaks and the occasional Friday to make up time.

With a Friday/Saturday weekend, my social life has been strange to say the least: people are rarely free on the workday of Friday, but I am never free for any of the fun things people want to do on a lazy Sunday. I've missed Easter dinners and Super Bowls, afternoons in the park and all sorts of other activities. Working until late has it's disadvantages too: never being able to make it to readings without taking vacation time (in 3.5 years in Iowa City, I've made it to Matt Hart, Forrest Gander, Johannes and Joyelle, Lyn Hejinian and Dean Young- that's all- It's Iowa City- we get amazing readings!)

One thing I have had though, is an advantage: considering everyone, including Jennifer, has been busy most Fridays, I have spent this time as wisely as possible. Yeah, sometimes I end up playing video games or watching TV. Sometimes I end up going to the mall and sometimes I can't tell where my Friday went!

Mostly though, Friday has been my Poetry Day: the day I sit down to read thoroughly, take notes, and catch up on my own writing ideas that I've been scribbling down all week. I read blogs all week, certainly, but it is on Friday that I try to really get into what has been going on in the online poetry community we seem to be a part of (as Johannes say, "glorified thing "The Blog Writer""). I take Friday as my day that I am not an employee, but someone whose primary interest in life is an art form and everything that goes on around it.

This has taken great dedication, especially considering that I took part in the International Writing Program's Translation Workshop on Friday afternoons for the last two Fall semesters. And by the end of those semesters, I felt like I was dragging and behind and unable to comprehend what had been going on while I had been in class. I wrote during odd hours, especially at work or late at night. I read poetry only when I needed to (like reading poets at schools I applied to). I kept up with blogs and blogging, but if you look back over my posts from the last 8 months or so, the frequency is inconsistent, to say the least.

To know now, that in some small way, this has paid off, I am happy:

Last Friday, I was called by one of the MFA programs I had applied to an offered admission for next Fall. After four years of applying, most of which was to the University of Iowa's Writer's Workshop, since they're in my back yard and all, it has been a truly gratifying experience to know that giving one solid day to my "hobby" was a good idea.

But it's not a hobby as much as it used to be. The idea that everyday can be this way to some extent (minus teaching or other work related to surviving through an MFA) is such a wonderful feeling, and maybe a bit scary too. That I have at least one place saying that my faith in myself as a poet and as a person whose intellectual curiousity has led to considering language and all its trappings as the basic underpinning of our relationships and culture as a whole has been such a fantastic feeling this last week.

I'm not done though: of the 13 schools I applied to, this has been the only one I have heard from so far. I am going to do my best to keep my head straight through this process and hopefully I'll be able to pick the right school for me at this point. This is assuming I have an option, but if I don't, I have nothing but positive feelings about my one acceptance and would be honored to matriculate there this Fall.
_________________________________________

Poetry Day for me has been an escape to some extent, a double-life as someone who hasn't been doing what he's been wanting to do. Fridays are a way of pretending that I'm someone I am not, but hope to be. Fridays have been a way for me to distance myself from my forty hour week and keep myself from giving in to the feeling that I'd never get out of it. I had been desperate, certainly, to move on "career"-wise (assuming anything like that still exists for today's MFA graduate). But even getting into school is a wonderful step in the direction I want to go and it's a lovely feeling.
_________________________________________

It occurred to me last night that what had been a "hobby" for the last decade of my life, minus a few stints in creative writing classes while at Georgia, is now a "job" of sorts. This is great news! While in Johannes and Brian Henry's classes, one in Spring of 04 and the other in Spring of 05, I thrived under the pressure of needing to have something to present on certain weeks. I recall especially while in Johannes' class that my output was quite high, though obviously not all of it was stellar. I'm really looking forward to having to write, as right now, it's something I do because I want to, so, Poetry Day or not, I have to make myself do it. External pressure will make this great.
_________________________________________

For those keeping score, that's 1 acceptance, and 12 undecideds. I hope to hear something soon from the others.

11/17/08

The Trivedi Chronicles Present: The Official Song of the 2008-2009 M.F.A. Application Season

It's an odd choice, no doubt, but here it is, in YouTube form:



Some lyrics which made the decision easier for me:

1.
I got some money in my pocket about ready to burn
I don't remember where I got it, I gotta get it to you

2.
You keep telling me I've got everything; You say I've got everything I want
You keep telling me you're gonna help me, you're gonna help me but you don't
But now I'm in too deep
It's got me so that I just can't sleep
Get me out of here; Please get me out of here
Just help me, I'll do anything if you just help me get out of here

3.
Please get me out of here
Someone get me out of here
Just help me I'll do anything, anything
If you'll just help get me out of here
Tonight I'm gonna make it right
Tonight, tonight, tonight.


Also, though no one asked, here is the final list of MFA programs I applied/am applying to (in some sub-concious order, i.e. the order in which they popped into my head):

1. Brown University
2. University of Massachusetts-Amherst
3. University Texas at Austin
4. University of Michigan
5. Indiana University
6. University of Alabama
7. Washington University, St. Louis
8. University of Notre Dame
9. Illinois State University (M.A. program)
10. Syracuse University
11. University of Arkansas
12. University of Mississippi (Ole Miss)
13. Columbia College, Chicago

10/22/08

Two Americas

Bill Maher is right: there are two Americas.

One America wants to be a socially progressive, European state and the other America wants to be an uptight, backwards society where people don't have to pay taxes to a government that allows all the guns you want and barges into your bed room to make sure you're having sex with a member of the opposite gender. That government has every right to your body and no rights to your money or arsenal.

One America wants to make it so that Americans can prosper by taking care of each person's basic needs (like healthcare). The other America wants to make it so that if you're not pulling yourself up by the bootstraps, you're being trampled at the bottom by those richer than you.

One America thinks it's ok to scare people by saying Gays will take over the country if allowed to marry, and the other America thinks that two people, regardless of gender, should be allowed to enter into a marital contract with another person.

One America wants to scare people into hating Gays.

Can you guess which America that is?

8/20/08

Fashion Poetics #3: Art’s Double Life

Inspired my Johannes’ near-constant blog posts, I’ve been thinking a great deal about the channels of poetry.

The mainstream: the stuff you can pick up at Barnes and Noble that is relatively easy to read and can be considered worth reading and “beautiful.”

The other/experimental/difficult/abstract/challenging/elite/outsider: you’re probably ordering it online or you’ve got a good bookstore in town. Probably not “beautiful” and probably not as accessible, however you define it.

In fact, what defines accessibility is a damn fine question: anyone who can answer it (if anyone’s even reading this) gets a cookie! What makes a poem “difficult” to read? What is it about Keats that high school students “get” that they don’t get about others? Is it the way Keats and other Romantics are taught in schools? I suppose the idea of the canon is that it becomes what poetry is for people throughout their lives- when they like it at 16, perhaps they find comfort in buying it again at 36 without wanting to look for something new.

Perhaps the average reader isn’t about the “experiment,” but are MFA students now to try and go beyond the quasi-academic audience that inevitably picks up modern poetry? On one hand, to reach a larger audience would make sense, but what does that larger public want? While it is impossible to define what the poetry counterpublic desires because it is not one mass, at least there is some idea of what one is getting into within subpublics. However, the larger public requires a level of canonization that most poets just starting out will probably never get to- and I’m guessing a majority probably don’t want to get there.

But then there is the limit of the counterpublic that is being set. Obviously there’s no number, but of course there’s the range of people we’re including. There are academics and those just beyond it (I’m including myself in the beyond for now, though I’m a wannabe). Who else is reading unless they’ve been involved in some way with creative writing and workshops somewhere?

While you may not have to accept the limits of poetry and language itself, I think there has to be an admission about the limits of audience and public in the "poetry world", which I know is a phrase many around me would disagree with. There is no poetry world, they would argue, but I believe it has been created as such, and to an extent, there may be no way around it.

But I wonder: aren't I creating a canon simply be creating opposition? And while this is a good moment to mention that I want to avoid a binary situation, is it possible for something to be both mainstream and more obscure? Doesn't someone like Pinsky, who's famous enough that no less than Lisa Simpson went to a reading of his, seem kind of silly publishing a chapbook, something generally left for those that are up and comers in poetry circles? While there's no reason Pinsky should be excluded from publishing whatever he wants to publish, somehow the idea that Pinsky had to settle for a smaller publication seems ridiculous to me. Maybe it's even a little insulting to us little guys that he can do something which we find difficult so easily.

Anyways, I wonder if there's a time element to mainstream that has yet to happen with contemporary poetry. Were people reading Eliot or Pound in large numbers at the time? Would anyone have predicted that lines from Eliot would be used in movies or other such things? It would be hard to argue that Apocalypse Now has no public.

I suppose the reason I wanted to come back to the awful Fashion Poetics analogy was to say this one point: because it exists beyond the public, as a counterpublic, non-mainstream poetry has room to do whatever it wants. The threads don't have to stay together so long as the dress itself looks interesting, experimental, and new. I would argue, in fact, that the threads don't even have to hold and that at the points where the dress rips is where you have real fashion and "real poetics." Mainstream poetry- Garrison Keillor's best poems set or whatever- must have a certain "beauty" to it or it won't be pulled off the shelf at Barnes and Noble while you're kid is screaming to go to Kay-Bee Toys next door. There's a standard the mainstream must achieve and because no one outside of the poetry counterpublic cares about it, counterpublic poetics can avoid and continue setting its own goals on language, thematics/politics, and whatever else.

Fashion Poetics #1
Fashion Poetics #2

4/13/08

Fashion Poetics #2

Cristine, the smartest person in the worst class I took at UGA, English Literature before 1700, commented on my previous Fashion Poetics post:

"No, but I do think you're an ass if you're suggesting, and I am afraid you may be, that Keats is not an artistic poet simply because he is widely anthologized? If this is the case then you should revisit Keats."

I'm not saying it's Keats' fault by any means. Nor is it really the fault of any poet who becomes popular. I'm sure at some point, Pinsky thought of himself as an outsider poet, but as he became popular and a pop culture symbol, he should have attempted, if he was able, to point more towards changing landscapes rather than attempting to capitalize on his fame in publishing just to get more poems out there. However, I don't think that's what his poetics was ever about, which maybe why he was popular.

Keats, especially due to his young death, had no idea at the time he would become the canon. Pinsky and Collins are guys that seemed to take advantage of their position, attempting to staying free of the experimental poetry argument.

***

Watching Tyra Banks' America's Next Top Model, I took note of a situation where the designer told the group of girls that the clothes were very delicate and that any major movements would rip their precious threads. I wondered to myself, "What's the point of such a cloth or article of clothing?" It was then that I thought again about fashion poetics and how this was not functional clothes design but the design and construction of clothing as art. Models are simply an easel, I guess.

And I came to think about poetry again and how, as in every art form, there are pieces for mass consumption and those that function within the art's circle. I don't think this is anything new: there has always been popular fiction and art fiction, but now the academy is deciding what constitutes non-pop literature. Poets needed jobs in order to survive, so now there is a mass movement of a group. Poetry as a counterpublic, to use Michael Warner.

I think to some extent this comes back to a question Johannes had about "difficult poems": generally, people don't want to have to work at anything, so poems become "difficult" when they cannot immediately discern meaning. Keats' poems are not complex poems in terms of meaning, which is why I believe he is a part of the high school canon. I believe there is a directness in Romantic poetry that makes it easy for a high school student to get through without having to delve too deeply into what is really going on. Perhaps that hardest thing a high school student would ever have to encounter is Cummings. I believe the existence of the canon can be traced to those who prefer poetry they don't have to work at understanding.

For those outside of art, it's about finding a way to make sense of what they are being shown. This usually comes to some kind of quantifiable measure like ratings and profits. 'Twin Peaks' may have been one of the best shows the television had the luck of displaying, but because it did not make immediate sense to suits and the public, it was considered unworthy of a good slot on the schedule. Eventually Lynch grew tired and quit working on it.

I think too there's some compulsion towards love in everything: movies, television, novels, and especially poems. It's easy to understand topics of love because it's something we're all nearing on an obsession with. Life seems most nearly to be about the relationships with those around us and so to have poems that address that issue in an easy manner is what people want to read. "La Belle Dame Sans Merci" paints a picture that is easy to understand and in some cases, easy to identify with. Who can count on their fingers the number of people around them who have gone through similar feelings to the knight? Certainly I cannot.

The group of people I know write poems that are meant to be worn delicately, but don't take that to mean the poems themselves are delicate. Like I said, the issue with fashion poetics is that it's not about mass consumption but rather about the exploration of language and culture through poetic means. Ultimately, this is what fashion is about to, but don't let the stitching get in the way of a complex design.

The fashion poetics metaphor isn't the best, I know, but it does help me illustrate what I'm beginning to understand about a poetry counterpublic. My hope is to work on this in the future with some further thinking and research. I'm not necessarily sure where to begin, but since this is, so far, an individual pursuit and not yet an academic one, I guess I'm on my own time.

2/14/08

A Fashion Poetics?

I was watching “Project Runway” on Bravo! the other night when it occurred to me that fashion is an art form. Yes, I realize most people already know this, but I was surprised to discover that not everyone is in it to sell their clothes to your average “Soccer Mom”. I’ve been watching Project Runway off and on since the beginning and it finally hit me last night that there’s fashion for people, but there’s also fashion for art. There’s fashion theory, much in the way one could read Derrida or Deleuze and hopefully go in some direction with poems. One could go to an art museum and end up with a poem or an article of clothing or a short film. It’s all connected.

But I also thought this phrase I have written- ‘Fashion Poetics’- has its downside. There is commercial poetry- poetry people buy and read to say they love poetry. Poetry for a rainy day, a sunny day, a blue day and a great day. Poems for birthdays and poems for death. Your Barnes and Noble anthologies or whatever you want to call them. Fashion Poetics must not be the commercial but the ‘art’; not the conventional but the experiment. Not the building up, but the breaking down.

Speaking of experiments, in Dee’s class we’ve been talking about Documentary Poetics. Reznikoff, Rukeyser, Mike Gold. Social Realism. Our assignment was to find a document and then write a poem based on it. I chose a section from Jennifer’s FEMA courses on disasters, and thus the poem came to be titled and about terrorism. I think it turned out OK and illuminated a few moments of their material:

       Acts of terrorism include
       threats of terrorism.

I might post it at some point, who knows. It’s not the greatest poem ever, but I don’t feel like it’s terrible for what it is.

Anyways, what I guess I learned from this process is that while some of these projects come out very stale (Tillie Olsen), I feel like this kind of poetry has a small place, but that perhaps it’s in more a commercial vein than an artistic one. Though sometimes the two come together?

Maybe, but maybe not. Call this view elitist (and it is), but I think there’s a difference between in-industry artistry and commercial consumption. I think this is why the NEA funds some folks and not others or why Robert Pinksy was on The Simpsons. I think art must maintain its double life. I think there are people that want to sit and study contemporary art forms and there are people that want a pair of pants that don’t make their assess look huge.

But should it strive to be more? Should art be what is getting out to people so that when they hear they the word poem, they don’t immediately recall Robert Frost or Keats? Is this even possible?

Not really, though I imagine many of the folks I know would think me an ass for even suggesting that there be a line. In fact, that I’m trying to say is that there is a line that can’t be erased, and that perhaps it doesn’t need erasing.

Your average Barnes and Noble visitor won’t read and maybe doesn’t need to read Graham Foust. Poetry, certainly, has become for other poets. We’re our own industry, self-sustaining, and perhaps this is what it must be. How can it possibly go backwards now?

Fashion poetics is by nature elitist poetics. Though I wish it didn't have to be.

1/23/08

Back in the (Proverbial) Saddle (Again)

I'm taking a non-degree graduate level course here at Iowa. Professor Dee Morris is teaching a course on the Anti-Lyric under her umbrella of "What Else Can Poetry Do?"

It feel great to be back in class and to be doing it for a grade this time. There's something at stake here and I'm hoping it goes well.

Michelle, a Workshopee, is in the class with me, so it's very nice to know someone. We discussed blogs- a discussion Dee seemed curious about. I, for one, am embarrassed by some of the blogs I read, even 'poetry blogs'.

There are lots of questions to be asked here about what a poetry blog *ought* to be or *ought* to contain. I really couldn't tell you honestly, but I know that very few blogs really maintain their manifestations has poetry blogs.

Hmm, blogs and poetry = future research topic?

We shall see. For now, I'm happy just being able to intoduce myself in class without shaking...